Social practices around mobile gaming
Posted: March 10th, 2009 | 4 Comments »
This picture of kids I encountered in Japan in 2004 playing with a game-boy exemplify one of the most intriguing feature I observe in gaming: a situation where only one person has a game device and the others are participating without it, in their own way. This is a common situation in gaming, one can also observe it on game consoles (where one person plays with the pad and the other helps in a less formal way).
In their paper presented at CHI 2008 “Renegade Gaming: Practices Surrounding Social Use of the Nintendo DS Handheld Gaming System“, Christine Szentgyorgyi, Michael Terry & Edward Lank describes an interesting exploration of the social practices related with a mobile game platform. Unlike my picture above, they investigated players who had their own mobile consoles. Based on a qualitative study, the authors studied how players engage in multiplayer games via ad-hoc, wireless networking and how it affects the social gaming practices.
In their results, they identify three themes related to the multiplayer gaming practices of the Nintendo DS:
“ renegade gaming, or the notion that users reappropriate contexts traditionally hostile to game play; pragmatic and social barriers to the formation of ad-hoc pick-up games, despite a clear desire for multiplayer, collocated gaming; and private gaming spheres, or the observation that the handheld device’s form factor creates individual, privatized gaming contexts within larger social contexts.“
The paper provides informative elements about these themes and also tackles their design implications:
“we focus on two particularly salient design implications suggested by the data, namely better support for ad-hoc, pick-up gaming, and mechanisms to expand the social gaming experience
(…)
Mechanisms that allow one to more easily locate other local DS gamers, invite a player to a multiplayer game via the DS itself, join preexisting games, and gracefully exit games would all help address the desire for pick-up games. The implementation of these suggestions is certainly technically feasible for a system such as the DS
(…)
To help create a broader social context, the system could provide provisions to externally display game state on a shared display so non-players could observe game action. “
Why do I blog this? gathering material for a potential project about social gaming practices for a client. This is quite an exciting topic and I am try to collect some material about it in the context of mobile games. I am quite sure that lessons can be learned from the Nintendo DS and that it would be possible to transfer them into a cell-phone context.
Mobile gaming could be big if played via wifi or bleutooth and games must be playable on all types of phones. Sony Ericsson is experimenting a lot with Gameloft at the moment.
I am not sure how this connects to the questions you pose, but viewing this picture immediately triggers thoughts about how sharing media can be seen as a kind of ‘gift exchange’ in the cultural anthropological sense. See Marcel Mauss’ classic essay “The Gift” (1924) and Malinowski’s work on Trobrianders (1922). Important objects are passed from hand to hand in gift circles to establish and negotiate social relationships between people. Gifting has to conform to three basic rules: one has to give, one has to accept, and one has to reciprocally give gifts of equal value. Objects often move asymetrically (e.g. one of these kids owns the DS, the other kids have other things to share). Gift theory has been applied many times to various new media practises (open source software; game cheats; mobile phone texting). It can consist of ‘virtual’ gifts but also to technological objects (passing along a phone to use, call credit, or gameboys). I think Jenkins recently posted some stuff about gifting as well: http://henryjenkins.org/2009/02/if_it_doesnt_spread_its_dead_p_2.html.
I’ve got ‘some’ exprience on mobile games testing and mobile multiplayer games. It seems that closer the players are to each other, the more fun it is. Mobile games that can be played with two devices are a bit dull. Bluetooth games (range around 8m) are bit more fun. Games requiring players to share single device simultaneously are the most fun. =) E.g. see Digital Chocolote games Jungle Rumble or Sumo Smash.
[...] Pasta&Vinegar : Pratiques sociales autour du jeu mobile (angl.) Nicolas Nova signale une intéressante étude sur les usages sociaux des consoles DS qui identifie [...]